Reviews for Pettinari's Deli & Pizza

04/15/2025 - Lupita A.
This deli is a treasure trove of deliciousness, featuring homemade sausages that are to die for and a fantastic selection of fresh meats that make every meal a winner. Plus, with the sweetest chihuahua roaming around and a staff that treats you like family, I can't help but stop by weekly for my grocery fix!

06/16/2024 - Herman P.
Always good.

05/19/2021 - BELAIR
THEY ARE GETTING WOSE

07/26/2019 - Ed
Have been going there for years my go to place when throwing a big party pizza done on time and hot

05/20/2018 - Neil Belair
Been in Hilton since 1965---Been in Petts a million times--- TODAY
Had the worst sub of my life (5/20/18/) Ordered Italian Asstr'd----Got a huge loaf of bread ( sliced 1/4" thick on one side and 2" on the
other with 1 (ONE) piece of meat, a little tomatoe, a little red pepper, tiny piece of red onion
AND no more---
After all these years, you are history-----Neil Belair, 392-2290

08/27/2014 - N.Belair
Had to re-write--2nd sub was super-not sure what happened to the previous one--Belair

08/26/2014 - N. Belair
Been going to "PETTS" for years , been in Hilton since 1965
Todays SUBS were awful==very little meat, more bread than anything---They have gone downhill---They need to go to La Belllas and learn how to make a real sub---Unless they greatly improve, we are thru with Petts.---Belair, Hilton, NY