Reviews for Anthony's Family Pizza-Bexley

06/26/2025 - Krystal T.
House Favorite slice totally hit the spot with fresh ingredients and a perfectly thin crust that I'm still dreaming about. The vibe is super chill and fun, with antique ovens cranking out solid pizza that's just the right kind of no-fuss. The owner's charm and the friendly staff made the whole experience even better, and I can't wait to try more styles next time!

02/14/2025 - Brendan R.
The House Favorite slice at Anthony's Pizzeria is exceptional, making it the perfect choice for a busy moving day when good pizza is essential. With a vibrant and fun atmosphere, the restaurant features antique ovens that produce consistently delicious pies, and the owner's passion for pizza adds to the welcoming experience. The menu offers a variety of styles, including Chicago, Detroit, and New York, with fresh ingredients and great service that makes each visit memorable.

07/02/2024 - Jd B.
Always good food.

11/16/2010 - FoodDude10
As good as you are going to find! The stromboli was as good as I have ever eaten, and the pizza is extremely fresh.

09/08/2010 - Bexley Buckeye
WOW! Homemade and hand-rolled pizza dough along with the very best and freshest ingredients make these pizzas and stromboli the very best in the entire central Ohio area. NOT TO BE MISSED!

08/14/2010 - Pizza Lover in Berwick
Tonight was the first time we had their pizza since they reopened under new ownership. Pizza tastes fantastic! Fresh ingredients and they threw in a few home-made cookies on of it! How can you go wrong with that? I'd give them more than 5 stars if there was room for it.