Reviews for Mayflower Seafood

04/07/2024 - MenuPix User

03/24/2024 - MenuPix User

03/09/2024 - MenuPix User

01/25/2024 - MenuPix User

01/05/2024 - MenuPix User

01/04/2024 - MenuPix User

12/30/2023 - MenuPix User

12/17/2023 - MenuPix User

12/16/2023 - MenuPix User

11/22/2023 - MenuPix User

09/20/2023 - Penelope
Food always good hot an fresh. Never had a real problem. They got 1 order wrong quick to fix it. 1 order in how many years? Great customer service!!!

09/10/2023 - Ned
The Grouper both fried and broiled are fantastic

06/03/2023 - MenuPix User
I go to takeout most time love that the food is always hot and doesn't take a long time and the tarter sauce is really good.

07/16/2022 - MenuPix User
I went to pick up my food. The cashier was rude and almost got cussed out. The shrimp was overcooked and the fish looked and tasted fake. Mayflower need to do better!!!!

12/03/2021 - MenuPix User
Got a senior plate of food tonight. It was 25.00 This was for a senior shrimp plate and order suppose to be 12.99 for shrimp and deviled crab. My bill was almost 27.00. I called and girl was rude. I ask to speak to manager and she said she was. That was the same girl I spoke to in the beginning. She was mean and rude and told me if I could not afford it I should have ask. The food was horrible and she could have never have been taught any manners. Never again. I have saved this receipt cause she said I was looking at old prices.Never again.

07/10/2021 - Nancy McKee
I go there as often as I can always had excellent service excellent food and more food than I can eat at one time so plenty to take home

03/01/2021 - rwr
i ordered trout,shrimp and they were over cooked .want be going back.

02/17/2021 - MenuPix User
Been going there for years never had a bad experience or bad food

10/13/2020 - MenuPix User
great food and great service

10/13/2020 - george
Great food and service everytime I eat there or pick it up.

05/02/2020 - Stephanie
I went to Mayflower in Goldsboro NC. I ordered my food. I understand that they are just opening up, but when I got my food it smelled burnt. The food that I had gotten tasted burnt. I understand that they just opened up, but nobody food should smell or taste like it is burnt. 😒😒🙁🙁

04/11/2020 - Bob
Always good food and service

04/08/2020 - MenuPix User
So this was horrible and usually I can deal with everything I get. I ordered clam strips trout and fries. They change the fries to these crispy looking fries instead of crinkle. They was nasty. My clam strips was tough. The best Orr was some shrimp they accidentally put in my food. Mayflower really needs to remove its name from this restaurant. I have been to 5 mayflowers in N.C. This is the worse. There is even one in Greensboro that is also Italian. They were better than This.

12/04/2018 - Jerry E.
Dec. 2nd 2018. Just ate at Mayflower!
Service was super! Food was perfectly cooked & they gave us so much. Very reasonable priced!

Will go back!!!!!

04/07/2017 - Glenda
Took Mom today for her 81st birthday and our waiter brought us coffee. Then we ordered founder & shrimp. For sides we ordered baked potato w butter & sour creme. The other side was slaw. Hush puppies were included. It was all amazing and fresh! Our waiter was fast and polite. The charges were very reasonable and we tipped our waiter generously.

03/28/2015 - LKR
Affordable, decent seafood. OK atmosphere. Good service.

02/25/2015 - Dissatisfied customer
My husband and I went into Mayflower and the first thing I notice was the sanitation rating was "90". The individual that was working didn't speak, walked up to counter, grab the pad where you right down the order and drew a big X on the order sheet, then he looks at me, and then I give my order. I am a manager of a retail store and I know the importance of acknowledging our customers and at least making them feel like a customer. I don't think I will be eating here again. Great customer service goes a long ways especially when you have a "90" as sanitation grade.