Reviews for Koffmeyer's Old Fashioned Cookies and Ice Cream

08/17/2025 - Mike M.
The ice cream here is rich, creamy, and offers a wide variety of unique flavors that I haven't found anywhere else, complemented perfectly by their amazing homemade cookies. The staff are generally friendly and helpful, though I've noticed that during slower times, cleaning could be better maintained to improve the overall experience. While the ambiance is nostalgic and inviting, some small service hiccups, like serving sizes and closing time manners, could be improved, but I'm already looking forward to trying more flavors and treats on my next visit.

07/21/2024 - Adam C.
The ice cream at this establishment is truly delicious, and the staff members are very friendly. It would be beneficial if they could utilize their downtime to tidy up the tables and floors to ensure a cleaner environment for customers. While the serving size of the ice cream sundae was a bit small, the overall experience was enjoyable and the ice cream flavors were unique and tasty.