Reviews for Red Eye Cookie Co.

07/03/2025 - Kyle S.
There's something magical about pulling a warm, gooey cookie from its sleeve, the soft center almost melting in your hands like a fleeting moment of bliss. One evening, after a late-night craving led us across the street, we savored each bite of macadamia nut, oatmeal raisin, and chocolate chip varieties-each bursting with flavor and freshness that felt almost homemade. The friendly service and cozy, inviting atmosphere make every visit feel like a sweet escape, leaving me eager to explore even more flavors.

02/05/2025 - Scot C.
The cookies here are truly the best I've tasted in a long time, rivaling even my wife's baking. After a last-minute decision to provide cookies for a meeting, the staff were incredibly accommodating and had everything ready right on time. Every visit keeps me coming back for more, especially for the snickerdoodle and cookies & cream; they're simply irresistible.

04/24/2024 - Gregory H.
AWESOME