Reviews for Gaetano's of Berlin

07/22/2025 - Ka G.
Gaetano's serves an amazing Jersey Steak loaded with plenty of meat, potatoes, onions, and A-1 sauce on a soft seeded roll that always tastes fresh without being greasy. Their cheese pizzas are huge, made with fresh ingredients, and worth driving a bit further for, while the staff is friendly and the service usually smooth even on busy nights. Although prices are a bit on the higher side, the generous portions and quality make it well worth it, especially for cheesesteak lovers like me.

05/19/2024 - R T.
it is good

12/19/2016 - Tam
I order a cheesesteak which hardly had any meat like what Gaetano's us known for...it was basically bread sandwhich...and the meat that waz there which was not much was mostly dried up burnt scrapings of beef..it wax terrible!! I mean the worst steak i have evr had..i will never order from there again!! Cant believe i paid 8.75 for a mini cheesesteak..that wasnt worth 1 buck..soo disappointed!!! This place Gaetano's in berlin nj doent even deserve 1 star..awful awful!!!! Yuck yuck!!!