Reviews for Judys Famous Pies

11/20/2019 - MenuPix User
Great pies no idea what happend to those whom rated less, may have accidentally went to Rosie's instead!

09/03/2017 - Robyn pomnitz
Last year was our first for judys pies. And they were delicious! This year not. Totally different. Top crust heavy cookie dough. Not pie dough. Raw dough. And filling half gone. Dont bother calling. I did. She said i dont know what to tell you. So sad

03/16/2016 - Don
We got a small cherry ,blue berry ,Kentucky derby pie. All three were great .

08/03/2015 - Beek
Brought lemon meringue and raspberry pies. Both were mediocre in my opinion. The lemon filling was fluorescent yellow and gel like. Tasted like canned filling. The pie was pretty with lots of meringue. They said they make their own fillings. If they do, change recipe and use real eggs and lemons. Ditch artificial colors. The raspberry had too much cornstarch in filling and was also heavy gel consistency, but it did have lots of real raspberries. Tasted good if they had not gone overboard with corn starch it would have passed into excellent. Crust was standard. So far best pies I have had have been from Aschatz and my own. So in comparison I will not be back unless they change things and improve the fillings.