Reviews for Neighbor's Mill Bakery & Cafe

07/24/2025 - Geraldine E.
Mike, Karin, Cary, and their entire team deliver fresh, delicious meals and baked goods with friendly, attentive service that makes every visit enjoyable. From the massive cinnamon rolls to the flavorful sandwiches and salads, each bite is a testament to quality, while the warm atmosphere and courteous staff create a welcoming dining experience I look forward to repeating.

06/01/2024 - Gareth G.
Awesome

11/09/2021 - Gribbon
This is my very favorite place to eat. I have never ever had a bad meal here! Everything is so fresh, delicious and made the way you ask! And the coffee"¦..!!! And the service"¦..!!! I seriously think I'd suffer withdrawal symptoms if Neighbor's Mill ever goes away. Anytime I'm visiting other places and states, I hunt down SWEET TOMATOES, PANERA BREAD and the like. None of them are as good as our local Neighbor's Mill.

04/14/2021 - Ann-Marie LeBlanc
I travel through here regularly over the past 10 years. This restaurant is consistently clean and the service and food are excellent.
I drove 8 hours in one day to get one of their Lemon Blueberry Cakes...it's THAT good.