Delivery
No delivery
Payment
Credit Cards Accepted
Parking
Parking Lot
Good for Kids
No
Attire
Casual
Alcohol
Full Bar
Reservations
No
Est in 1994 Mustang Shelly's has worked hard to bring you over the top service, the best bar food, & enjoyable atmosphere.
| 5 star |
|
|
9 reviews | 35% | |
| 4 star |
|
|
9 reviews | 35% | |
| 3 star |
|
|
7 reviews | 27% | |
| 2 star |
|
|
1 review | 4% | |
| 1 star |
|
|
0 reviews | 0% |
08/26/2025 - Consuelo M.
The jambalaya and burgers here are consistently delicious, with tacos that stand out as some of the best around, especially on Thursdays when fresh salsa and chips are served. The rustic, cabin-inspired setting creates a casual and welcoming atmosphere, enhanced by attentive staff and an owner who genuinely connects with guests. Whether stopping by for flavorful drinks or a satisfying meal, the quality and friendly service make every visit enjoyable and worth repeating.
03/23/2025 - George H.
The jambalaya and burgers are fantastic, complemented by a rustic cabin atmosphere and attentive staff, including the owner who engages with patrons. With delicious food, great drink specials, and a friendly vibe, I'm already looking forward to returning after next weekend's basketball tournament!
02/08/2022 - Folks
We stopped there last summer for a burger but was told that all they offered were tacos or taco salad. When asked if we couldn't get a burger, they said no we've changed our kitchen around so we only offer tacos. Very disappointed, won't be back.
04/03/2021 - Pam and Steve M
Excellent food and generous portions. Friendly staff who are helpful with meal suggestions. Prices very reasonable for the generous portions. Every time we've stopped, it's been 5 star. âï¸âï¸âï¸âï¸âï¸
See all restaurants in New Berlin
