81% say Yum
67 people voted
81% say Yum
67 people voted
People Who Viewed This Also Viewed
Local Table and Tap ($$)
Burgers, International, American, Cafe
Fat Lady Cafe ($$)
Sorella Pizzeria and Restaurant ($)
Luzon Station ($$)
| Add Photo
Is this your restaurant? Click to add your description here.
Mon-Tue: 12pm - 9pm, Wed: Closed, Thu: 12pm - 9pm, Fri-Sat: 12pm - 10pm, Sun: 11am - 9pm
Credit Cards Accepted
Yes - Full Bar
$ - Cheap Eats (Under $10)
$$ - Moderate ($11-$25)
$$$ - Expensive ($25-$50)
$$$$ - Very Pricey (Over $50)
Good for Kids
Reviews of Fat Lady Cafe
05/31/2014 - Margretto
I LOVE this place. The food was absolutely amazing. My husband and I enjoyed every bite. The owner is very nice and takes pride in the food served. The crab bisque was to die for and the fresh homemade desserts served with fresh homemade whipped cream were out of this world. Everything we ate was wonderful. I can not say enough about this place. I have read people say this place is pricey, in my opinion you are getting quality food made with local and organic ingredients the food is priced right. I will come back again and again and again!
01/13/2013 - Nadege Hoeper
Finally got to experience this amazing restaurant! My parents and I were a little nervous about the price at first (because of some of the reviews I had read) but we were totally proven otherwise!
My mom enjoyed a wonderful LARGE glass of wine and my dad enjoyed a tasty dark organic winter sam adams on tap. The dinner began with a fresh, warm whole grain/seed/everything bread with herbed dipping oil- so tasty!! We were then served refreshing salads made with all dark leaves fresh carrots and onions and an amazing house dressing! In perfect time we received our meals- mom got the seafood dish (scallop & crab stuffed flounder with a miraculous sauce which totally made the dish), dad got the chicken franchIesse (incredibly tender and tasty), and i got the grass fed beef hanger steak- THE MOST AMAZING STEAK WE HAVE EVER HAD....since we all had to share our plates with one another. Each dish was served with freshly sauteed spinach or freshly steamed string beans.
We were overwhelmingly pleased with the experience of the Fat Lady Cafe, WOW.
08/26/2012 - Dave
My father and myself had the Cajun Lobster and I have to say that it was the best dish I had eatten in the last 5 years. The chef (Jay) was fantastic, the service was top shelf, and the restaurant was very clean. Overall, I give the Fat Lady the highest marks. On a scale of 1 to 10 I give it an 11.
Keep up the good work !!!!!!
07/21/2010 - ellen
just awful. no service. below average food. higher prices than warranted.
I love their food. The restaurant is clean and the food is fresh. I only wish they made general Tao 's chicken with more meat, it is too crispy with ...
Spiro's Countryside Restaurant
This restaurant is a gem, one of our favorite dinner places in the Catskills. The chef and owner Spiro is a superb human being. You can feel at home h...
Brother Bruno Pizza Restaurant
I ordered food last night let me tell you it was horrible. I ordered a dozen baked clams I still can't find the clams and the bread crumbs were mush. ...
Great restaurant. The food is wonderful & the staff is terrific. We've never been anything but pleased whenever we have eaten at the Gristmill. Tr...
Let me start by saying I have been to this restaurant many times before and could not rave about it more. But last night I had one of the most disappo...