Bay Shore Italian Restaurants

• 
  ITA Kitchen ($$)
  

  Italian • Menu Available

  45 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY
  (631) 267-5916 (631) 267-5916

  Write a Review!
• 
  Pie At Salvatore's ($$)
  

  Italian, Pizza • Menu Available

  120 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY
  (631) 206-1060 (631) 206-1060

  Write a Review!
• 
  Joe's Pizza ($$)
  

  Italian, Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches • Menu Available

  73 Howells Rd, Bay Shore, NY
  (631) 665-2524 (631) 665-2524

  Write a Review!
• 
  Mulberry Street ($$)
  

  Italian, Pizza • Menu Available

  192 Howells Rd, Bay Shore, NY
  (631) 665-2004 (631) 665-2004

  Write a Review!
• 
  Fratelli Pizzeria ($$)
  

  Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches, Italian, Fast Food • Menu Available

  553 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY
  (631) 666-0458 (631) 666-0458

  Write a Review!
• 
  Buseto Pizza ($)
  

  Italian, Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches • Menu Available

  1851 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY
  (631) 665-4939 (631) 665-4939

  Write a Review!
• 
  Frank & Maria's Italian Pork Store ($$)
  

  Deli, Italian, Sandwiches • Menu Available

  10 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY
  (631) 665-0047 (631) 665-0047

  Write a Review!
• 
  Olive Garden Italian Restaurant ($$)
  

  Italian • Menu Available

  1715 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY
  (631) 665-5213 (631) 665-5213

  Write a Review!
• 
  Bella Vie ($$)
  

  Italian, Seafood • Menu Available

  240 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY
  (631) 500-9045 (631) 500-9045

  Write a Review!
• 
  The Classic New York Pizza Joint ($$)
  

  Italian, Pizza • Menu Available

  2042 Sunrise Hwy Service Rd, Bay Shore, NY
  (631) 619-6900 (631) 619-6900

  Write a Review!
• 
  Valentinos Pizza ($)
  

  Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches, Italian, Peruvian • Menu Available

  1597 Manatuck Blvd, Bay Shore, NY
  (631) 666-5172 (631) 666-5172

  Write a Review!
• 
  Butera's Restaurant ($)
  

  Italian, Wine Bar, Pizza • Menu Available

  8 Third Ave, Bay Shore, NY
  (631) 328-4948 (631) 328-4948

  Write a Review!
• 
  Surf's Out ($$$) - Closed
  

  Italian, Seafood, Sushi, Catering • Menu Available

  1 Bay Walk, Bay Shore, NY
  (631) 583-7400 (631) 583-7400

  Write a Review!
• 
  La Casa Pizza & Pasta ($$) - Closed
  

  Pizza, Italian • Menu Available

  635 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY
  (631) 665-1010 (631) 665-1010

  Write a Review!
• 
  Paul's Pizza ($) - Closed
  

  Italian, Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches • Menu Available

  3 W Bay Shore Rd, Bay Shore, NY
  (631) 254-4240 (631) 254-4240

  Write a Review!
• 
  Soho Pizza & Bistro ($$) - Closed
  

  Italian, Pizza • Menu Available

  275 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY
  (631) 647-8989 (631) 647-8989

  Write a Review!
• 
  Yesterday's Cafe ($$) - Closed
  

  American, Italian, Bar Food • Menu Available

  31 East Main St, Bay Shore, NY
  (631) 647-4743 (631) 647-4743

  Write a Review!
• 
  De Natalie Pizzeria & Restaurant ($) - Closed
  

  Pizza, Italian • Menu Available

  222 5th Ave, Bay Shore, NY
  (631) 666-6388 (631) 666-6388

  Write a Review!
• 
  D'Franco's Pizzeria ($) - Closed
  

  Italian, Pizza • Menu Available

  2042 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY
  (631) 650-6939 (631) 650-6939

  Write a Review!
• 
  Mama's D's Italian Restaurant ($$) - Closed
  

  Italian • Menu Available

  424 W Montauk Hwy, Bay Shore, NY
  (631) 482-8374 (631) 482-8374

  Write a Review!