Upper West Area Restaurant Guide

• Cafe Fiorello ($$$)
  

  4.3 25 reviews
  Italian, Pizza

  1900 Broadway, New York, NY
  (212) 595-5330 (212) 595-5330
• Celeste ($$)
  

  3.8 49 reviews
  Italian, Pizza

  502 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY
  (212) 874-4559 (212) 874-4559
• Pappardella ($$)
  

  4.1 42 reviews
  Italian, Pizza, Gluten-Free, Wine Bar

  316 Columbus Ave, New York, NY
  (212) 595-7996 (212) 595-7996
• Patsy's Pizzeria ($$)
  

  4.0 24 reviews
  Italian, Pizza

  61 W 74th St, New York, NY
  (212) 579-3000 (212) 579-3000
• Bodrum Turkish Mediterranean ($$)
  

  4.2 22 reviews
  Turkish, Mediterranean, Pizza, Breakfast, Brunch

  584 Amsterdam Avenue, New York, NY
  (212) 799-2806 (212) 799-2806
• Freddie and Pepper's ($)
  

  4.4 39 reviews
  Pizza

  303 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY
  (212) 799-2378 (212) 799-2378
• Little Italy Pizza ($)
  

  4.2 42 reviews
  Italian, Pizza

  2476 Broadway, New York, NY
  (212) 787-6700 (212) 787-6700
• Francesco Pizzeria ($)
  

  4.0 39 reviews
  Italian, Pizza

  186 Columbus Ave, New York, NY
  (212) 721-0066 (212) 721-0066
• Uno Chicago Grill ($$)
  

  3.1 35 reviews
  Pizza, Italian, Subs

  432 Columbus Ave, New York, NY
  (212) 595-4700 (212) 595-4700
• Motorino ($$)
  

  4.3 34 reviews
  Pizza

  510 Columbus Ave, New York, NY
  (917) 675-7581 (917) 675-7581
• Bellini Italian Restaurant ($$)
  

  4.2 13 reviews
  Italian, Pizza

  483 Columbus Ave, New York, NY
  (212) 724-4615 (212) 724-4615
• Little Italy Pizza ($)
  

  3.8 49 reviews
  Italian, Pizza

  2047 Broadway, New York, NY
  (212) 362-8822 (212) 362-8822
• La Traviata ($)
  

  4.2 21 reviews
  Italian, Pizza

  101 W 68th St, New York, NY
  (212) 721-1101 (212) 721-1101
• Bourbon Street ($)
  

  3.0 17 reviews
  Bar Food, Pizza, Sports Bars

  407 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY
  (212) 721-1332 (212) 721-1332
• Pizza Pete's ($)
  

  4.0 15 reviews
  Italian, Pizza

  528 Columbus Ave, New York, NY
  (212) 787-3153 (212) 787-3153
• Famous Original Ray's Pizza ($)
  

  3.4 25 reviews
  Italian, Pizza

  462 Columbus Ave, New York, NY
  (212) 873-1134 (212) 873-1134
• 94 Corner Cafe ($)
  

  3.6 14 reviews
  Salads, Pizza, Sandwiches, Cafe

  2518 Broadway, New York, NY
  (212) 280-1900 (212) 280-1900
• Rosetta Bakery ($)
  

  4.8 10 reviews
  Bakery, Coffee Shop, Pizza

  1928 Broadway, New York, NY
  (917) 261-7686 (917) 261-7686
• Famous Famiglia ($)
  

  3.6 19 reviews
  Pizza

  734 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY
  (212) 864-7193 (212) 864-7193
• Pizza Collective ($$)
  

  4.4 10 reviews
  Pizza

  2060 Broadway, New York, NY
  (646) 693-0949 (646) 693-0949
• Domino's Pizza ($)
  

  5.0 1 review
  Pizza, Subs, Pasta, Wings

  148 W 72nd, New York, NY
  (212) 501-1800 (212) 501-1800
• Domino's Pizza ($)
  

  2.9 21 reviews
  Pizza, Subs, Pasta, Wings

  148 W 72nd St, New York, NY
  (212) 501-0200 (212) 501-0200
• Peperino NYC Pizza ($$)
  

  4.6 11 reviews
  Pizza, Italian, Wine Bar

  21 West End Ave, New York, NY
  (212) 245-2380 (212) 245-2380
• Saba's Pizza ($)
  

  4.0 26 reviews
  Pizza, Kosher, Falafel

  403 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY
  (212) 787-1118 (212) 787-1118
• Domino's Pizza ($)
  

  4.1 22 reviews
  Pizza, Subs, Pasta, Wings

  592 Columbus Ave, New York, NY
  (212) 496-5900 (212) 496-5900
• Mamma's Famous Pizza & Wings ($)
  

  3.9 16 reviews
  Pizza, Italian, American

  2345 Broadway, New York, NY
  (212) 362-8612 (212) 362-8612
• Health Nuts ($$)
  

  3.8 21 reviews
  Deli, Pizza, Health

  2611 Broadway, New York, NY
  (212) 678-0054 (212) 678-0054
• Bagels & Co. ($)
  

  4.3 24 reviews
  Sandwiches, Kosher, Bagels, Pizza

  393 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY
  (212) 496-9400 (212) 496-9400
• Famous Original Ray's Pizza ($)
  

  3.8 32 reviews
  Italian, Pizza

  2413 Broadway, New York, NY
  (212) 769-3636 (212) 769-3636
• Made In New York Pizza ($$)
  

  4.6 20 reviews
  Pizza

  421 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY
  (646) 484-6200 (646) 484-6200
• Jet's Pizza ($)
  

  4.5 4 reviews
  Pizza, Subs, Salads, Wings

  728 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY
  (646) 861-1605 (646) 861-1605
• Made In New York Pizza ($$)
  

  4.1 7 reviews
  Pizza

  271 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY
  (646) 449-8556 (646) 449-8556
• Parla ($$)
  

  5.0 2 reviews
  Pizza, Pasta

  320 Columbus Ave, New York, NY
  (212) 702-9006 (212) 702-9006
• Tavola Della Nonna ($)
  

  3.8 21 reviews
  Pizza, Italian, American

  208 W 70th St, New York, NY
  (212) 875-8600 (212) 875-8600
• Marinara Pizza ($)
  

  4.7 19 reviews
  Pizza, Italian

  483 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY
  (917) 265-8780 (917) 265-8780
• Village Square Pizza ($)
  

  4.0 1 review
  Pizza, Italian

  2479 Broadway, New York, NY
  (212) 901-3719 (212) 901-3719
• Bardolino Pizza 2 ($)
  

  4.2 13 reviews
  Pizza, Italian

  411 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY
  (646) 885-8316 (646) 885-8316
• Emmy Squared Pizza ($)
  

  4.4 8 reviews
  Pizza, Burgers

  200 West 60th St, New York, NY
  (929) 989-3669 (929) 989-3669
• Two Boots Pizza ($$)
  

  4.5 2 reviews
  Pizza

  70 W 71st St, New York, NY
  (646) 861-3970 (646) 861-3970
• Neapolitan Express ($$)
  

  4.6 11 reviews
  Pizza

  2109 Broadway, New York, NY
  (646) 704-9415 (646) 704-9415
• Song'E Napule ($)
  

  4.6 5 reviews
  Pizza, Italian

  464 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY
  (917) 472-7561 (917) 472-7561
• Mimi's Pizza ($)
  

  4.5 2 reviews
  Pizza

  2393 Broadway, New York, NY
  (212) 970-8887 (212) 970-8887
• Sogno Pizza ($)
  

  4.0 1 review
  Pizza

  2345 Broadway, New York, NY
  (212) 362-8612 (212) 362-8612
• Marinara Pizza ($)
  

  5.0 1 review
  Italian, Pizza

  2578 Broadway, New York, NY
  (646) 949-0995 (646) 949-0995
• Ray Bari Pizza ($)
  

  0.0 0 review
  Pizza

  201 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY
  (212) 595-8400 (212) 595-8400
• Bettola ($$) - Closed
  

  3.9 17 reviews
  Italian, Pizza

  412 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY
  (212) 787-1660 (212) 787-1660
• Big Nick's Burger Joint Too ($$) - Closed
  

  3.3 16 reviews
  Burgers, Diner, Pizza, Hot Dogs

  70 W 71st St, New York, NY
  (212) 799-4444 (212) 799-4444
• Caesar's Palace Pizza ($) - Closed
  

  3.6 7 reviews
  Italian, Pizza

  493 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY
  (212) 724-7886 (212) 724-7886
• Cafe Viva ($) - Closed
  

  3.9 28 reviews
  Italian, Kosher, Pizza, Vegetarian, Cafe

  2578 Broadway, New York, NY
  (212) 663-8482 (212) 663-8482
• Columbus Gourmet Food ($) - Closed
  

  3.6 9 reviews
  Pizza, Salads, Breakfast, Coffee Shop, Deli

  261 Columbus Ave, New York, NY
  (212) 721-7800 (212) 721-7800