Reviews for Upper Crust Bagel Co & Deli

08/07/2025 - Natalie B.
Coming from a New Yorker, I can say their bagels are absolutely amazing-crispy on the outside and soft and gooey on the inside, always fresh and delicious. The BLT on a plain bagel was incredible, with perfectly toasted bread, crisp bacon, and crunchy lettuce, making for a fantastic sandwich experience. The staff is friendly and helpful, the coffee and pastries are superb, and despite sometimes running out of popular bagel varieties early, I keep coming back for these unbeatable flavors.

07/14/2024 - Kimberly L.
Their bagels are a hit among New Yorkers, known for their light crispiness on the outside and soft, gooey texture inside. However, they tend to run out of popular flavors like egg and multigrain early in the day, which can be disappointing for customers. Despite this, the bagels are worth the visit for their delicious taste and the friendly service provided by the staff.