Herkimer County Restaurant Guide

• Crazy Ottos Empire Diner ($$)
  

  4.3 26 reviews
  Diner, American, Breakfast, Sandwiches, Coffee Shop

  100 W Albany St, Herkimer, NY
  (315) 866-8801 (315) 866-8801
• Old Mill Restaurant ($$$)
  

  3.6 18 reviews
  American, Barbecue, Sandwiches

  2888 State Route 28, Old Forge, NY
  (315) 369-3662 (315) 369-3662
• Yetty's Pizza ($$)
  

  3.6 45 reviews
  Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches

  109 Mohawk St, Herkimer, NY
  (315) 866-4201 (315) 866-4201
• Waterfront Grill ($$)
  

  4.4 19 reviews
  Grill, American, Sandwiches

  800 Mohawk St, Herkimer, NY
  (315) 717-0700 (315) 717-0700
• Walt's Diner ($)
  

  4.3 15 reviews
  Diner, American, Breakfast, Sandwiches

  3047 Main St, Old Forge, NY
  (315) 369-2582 (315) 369-2582
• Mountainside Lodge ($)
  

  4.4 14 reviews
  American, Burgers, Sandwiches, Barbecue

  5074 State Route 28, Old Forge, NY
  (315) 357-4371 (315) 357-4371
• Sorrento Pizzeria ($$)
  

  4.2 13 reviews
  Italian, Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches

  86 Central Ave, Ilion, NY
  (315) 894-9991 (315) 894-9991
• GiGi's Italian Feast ($$)
  

  4.2 15 reviews
  Italian, Pizza, Sandwiches, Brunch

  40 W Main St, Little Falls, NY
  (315) 823-0216 (315) 823-0216
• Ann Street Restaurant & Deli ($)
  

  4.0 23 reviews
  Cafe, Sandwiches, Breakfast

  381 Canal Place, Little Falls, NY
  (315) 823-3290 (315) 823-3290
• Tony's Pizzeria & Deli ($)
  

  3.9 45 reviews
  Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches

  435 Mohawk St, Herkimer, NY
  (315) 866-4593 (315) 866-4593
• Sandwich Chef ($$)
  

  4.8 12 reviews
  American, Cafe, Sandwiches

  604 E Main St, Little Falls, NY
  (315) 508-5192 (315) 508-5192
• Vinny's Pizzeria ($)
  

  4.3 15 reviews
  Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches

  322 S Caroline St, Herkimer, NY
  (315) 845-9504 (315) 845-9504
• Fratello's Pizzeria ($)
  

  3.7 41 reviews
  Italian, Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches

  158 E Main St, Frankfort, NY
  (315) 894-8484 (315) 894-8484
• New York Pizzeria ($)
  

  4.6 22 reviews
  Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches

  385 W Main St, West Winfield, NY
  (315) 822-6969 (315) 822-6969
• Primo Pizzeria ($)
  

  4.1 23 reviews
  Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches

  262 2nd St, Ilion, NY
  (315) 894-4500 (315) 894-4500
• Franco's Pizzeria ($)
  

  3.9 34 reviews
  Pizza, Burgers, Calzones, Wings, Sandwiches

  70 Central Plz, Ilion, NY
  (315) 894-5590 (315) 894-5590
• Red Door Dairy Store ($$)
  

  4.5 40 reviews
  Sandwiches, American

  661 US Hwy 20, West Winfield, NY
  (315) 822-3493 (315) 822-3493
• Paesano's Pizzeria ($)
  

  4.6 15 reviews
  Italian, Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches

  8 W Main St, Mohawk, NY
  (315) 866-0333 (315) 866-0333
• Dough a Deer ($$)
  

  4.4 13 reviews
  Bakery, Coffee Shop, Sandwiches

  3018 New York Hwy 28, Old Forge, NY
  (315) 369-0001 (315) 369-0001
• Bay Cafe ($$)
  

  4.0 1 review
  Bakery, Coffee Shop, Sandwiches, Subs

  5556 Hwy 28, Eagle Bay, NY
  (315) 357-2613 (315) 357-2613
• Adirondack Pizzeria ($)
  

  4.2 35 reviews
  Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches

  Main St, Old Forge, NY
  (315) 369-6028 (315) 369-6028
• Denny's ($)
  

  4.7 14 reviews
  Breakfast, American, Burgers, Sandwiches

  701 Mohawk St, Herkimer, NY
  (315) 866-1603 (315) 866-1603
• Dolgeville Bread Basket ($)
  

  4.9 10 reviews
  Bakery, Bagels, Sandwiches

  15 S Main St, Dolgeville, NY
  (315) 429-5215 (315) 429-5215
• Glazing Saddles Donuts and Eatery ($)
  

  4.6 8 reviews
  Donuts, Sandwiches, Breakfast

  2963 State Rte 28, Old Forge, NY
  (315) 369-1051 (315) 369-1051
• Carney's Corners ($$)
  

  3.1 20 reviews
  Pizza, Sandwiches

  232 N Washington St, Herkimer, NY
  (315) 866-7191 (315) 866-7191
• V-Ja's Lounge ($)
  

  4.5 61 reviews
  Bar Food, Burgers, Sandwiches

  307 E Main St, Frankfort, NY
  (315) 894-9735 (315) 894-9735
• Skobby's ($$)
  

  5.0 5 reviews
  Pizza, Wings, Sandwiches

  612 E Main St, Little Falls, NY
  (315) 556-1007 (315) 556-1007
• Dominick's Deli ($)
  

  4.7 22 reviews
  Deli, Sandwiches

  122 W Albany St, Herkimer, NY
  (315) 866-7669 (315) 866-7669
• Donna's Diner ($)
  

  4.7 3 reviews
  Diner, American, Breakfast, Sandwiches

  5616 State Route 5, Herkimer, NY
  (315) 866-1483 (315) 866-1483
• Lancia Pizza ($)
  

  5.0 3 reviews
  Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches

  2922 State Route 28, Old Forge, NY
  (315) 369-3744 (315) 369-3744
• Lombardo's Pizza Plus II ($)
  

  3.9 56 reviews
  Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches

  154 E Main St, Ilion, NY
  (315) 894-7111 (315) 894-7111
• Ina's Pizzeria ($)
  

  3.9 35 reviews
  Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches

  10 N Helmer Ave, Dolgeville, NY
  (315) 429-9175 (315) 429-9175
• Chick-fil-A ($)
  

  4.0 1 review
  Chicken, Sandwiches, Fast Food

  2576 State Rte 5S, Little Falls, NY
  (866) 232-2040 (866) 232-2040
• Kitlas Restaurant ($$)
  

  3.9 48 reviews
  Sandwiches, Deli

  2242 Broad St, Frankfort, NY
  (315) 732-9616 (315) 732-9616
• Arby's ($)
  

  4.1 18 reviews
  Sandwiches, Chicken, Salads, Fast Food

  306 E State St, Herkimer, NY
  (315) 866-7195 (315) 866-7195
• Corner Cafe ($$) - Closed
  

  5.0 1 review
  Sandwiches, American, Deli

  4 N Main St, Middleville, NY
  (315) 891-3468 (315) 891-3468
• Big Jim's ($$) - Closed
  

  5.0 1 review
  Sandwiches, Subs

  122 W Albany St, Herkimer, NY
  (315) 866-9914 (315) 866-9914
• 5 Corners Cafe ($$) - Closed
  

  5.0 4 reviews
  American, Cafe, Sandwiches

  3067 State Route 28, Old Forge, NY
  (315) 369-2255 (315) 369-2255
• Brian's Roast Beef Deli ($) - Closed
  

  4.0 2 reviews
  Deli, Sandwiches, American, Pizza

  122 N Main St, Herkimer, NY
  (315) 866-3664 (315) 866-3664
• Piccolo Cafe ($$) - Closed
  

  4.5 6 reviews
  Cafe, Sandwiches

  365 S Ann St, Little Falls, NY
  (315) 823-9856 (315) 823-9856
• Pizza Boys ($) - Closed
  

  3.8 6 reviews
  Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches

  268 N Main St, Herkimer, NY
  (315) 866-1010 (315) 866-1010
• Thats Amore Pizza & Pasta ($) - Closed
  

  4.0 14 reviews
  Pasta, Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches

  650 1/2 W German St, Herkimer, NY
  (315) 866-9777 (315) 866-9777
• Crabby's ($$) - Closed
  

  3.6 5 reviews
  American, Sandwiches, Subs, Seafood, Seafood Markets

  67 Flint Ave, Little Falls, NY
  (315) 823-3300 (315) 823-3300
• Froggy's ($) - Closed
  

  5.0 1 review
  American, Burgers, Hot Dogs, Sandwiches

  6 West Clark St, Ilion, NY
  (315) 894-1400 (315) 894-1400
• A J's Pizzeria & Deli ($) - Closed
  

  4.5 4 reviews
  Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches

  E F K Plz, Herkimer, NY
  (315) 866-4480 (315) 866-4480
• Ed & Bud's Grill ($) - Closed
  

  4.3 42 reviews
  Grill, American, Sandwiches

  16 W Main St, Little Falls, NY
  (315) 823-9832 (315) 823-9832
• Geno's Pizzeria ($) - Closed
  

  5.0 1 review
  Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches

  152 E Main St, Frankfort, NY
  (315) 894-2080 (315) 894-2080
• Greco's Pizzeria ($) - Closed
  

  5.0 2 reviews
  Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches

  3060 Main, Old Forge, NY
  (315) 369-2480 (315) 369-2480
• Hard Times Cafe ($) - Closed
  

  5.0 10 reviews
  Cafe, Sandwiches

  5521 County Route 28, Eagle Bay, NY
  (315) 357-5199 (315) 357-5199
• Jims Breakfast Lunch & Deli Cafe ($) - Closed
  

  5.0 1 review
  Deli, Sandwiches, American, Breakfast, Cafe

  428 N Washington St, Herkimer, NY
  (315) 717-0150 (315) 717-0150