Long Island Area Restaurant Guide

• Jordan Lobster Farms ($$)
  

  4.1 15 reviews
  Seafood Markets, Seafood

  1 Pettit Pl, Island Park, NY
  (516) 889-3314 (516) 889-3314
• Duryea's Lobster Deck ($$$)
  

  3.5 44 reviews
  Seafood, American, Seafood Markets

  65 Tuthill Rd, Montauk, NY
  (631) 668-2410 (631) 668-2410
• B@Bfish and clam ($$)
  

  4.3 19 reviews
  American, Seafood, Seafood Markets

  179 Merrick Rd, Amityville, NY
  (631) 608-0202 (631) 608-0202
• White Cap Fish ($$)
  

  3.8 21 reviews
  Seafood, Seafood Markets

  130 Montauk Hwy, Bay Shore, NY
  (631) 581-0125 (631) 581-0125
• Fish Store ($$)
  

  4.4 15 reviews
  Seafood Markets, Seafood, Sushi, Catering

  836 Montauk Hwy, Bayport, NY
  (631) 472-3018 (631) 472-3018
• Artie's South Shore Fish Grill ($$)
  

  4.3 47 reviews
  Seafood, Seafood Markets

  4257 Austin Blvd, Island Park, NY
  (516) 889-0692 (516) 889-0692
• Fish Store ($$)
  

  4.2 11 reviews
  Seafood Markets, Seafood, Sushi, Catering

  836 Montauk Hwy, Bayport, NY
  (631) 472-3018 (631) 472-3018
• Catfish Annies ($$)
  

  3.3 7 reviews
  American, Southern, Seafood, Seafood Markets

  116 Commack Rd, Commack, NY
  (631) 499-5131 (631) 499-5131
• Stuart Seafood Market Ltd ($$)
  

  4.7 22 reviews
  Seafood, Catering, Seafood Markets

  41 Oak Ln, Amagansett, NY
  (631) 267-6700 (631) 267-6700
• Billys By the Bay ($$)
  

  4.2 53 reviews
  American, Seafood Markets

  2530 Manhanset Ave, Greenport, NY
  (631) 477-8300 (631) 477-8300
• The Seafood Shop ($$$)
  

  4.8 24 reviews
  Seafood, Seafood Markets

  356 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY
  (631) 537-0633 (631) 537-0633
• New Wave Seafood ($$)
  

  4.5 22 reviews
  American, Seafood, Seafood Markets

  1847 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh, NY
  (516) 783-4900 (516) 783-4900
• Land & Sea Seafood Resturant ($$)
  

  3.4 14 reviews
  Seafood, Soups, Seafood Markets

  524 Route 25a, Mount Sinai, NY
  (631) 473-0011 (631) 473-0011
• Round Swamp Farm ($$$)
  

  4.2 24 reviews
  Farmers Market, Seafood Markets

  184 Three Mile Harbor Rd, East Hampton, NY
  (631) 324-4438 (631) 324-4438
• Braun Seafood 2 Go ($$)
  

  4.3 12 reviews
  Seafood, Seafood Markets

  30840 Main Rd, Cutchogue, NY
  (631) 734-7770 (631) 734-7770
• Northport Fish & Lobster ($$)
  

  4.3 9 reviews
  American, Seafood, Seafood Markets, Catering

  827 Fort Salonga Rd, Northport, NY
  (631) 757-3474 (631) 757-3474
• Sea World Sushi and Fish Market ($$)
  

  4.8 12 reviews
  Japanese, Seafood Markets

  201 N Long Beach Rd, Rockville Centre, NY
  (516) 766-0107 (516) 766-0107
• Marty's Gourmet Seafood ($$$)
  

  4.1 11 reviews
  Seafood, Seafood Markets

  266 New York Ave, Huntington, NY
  (631) 673-1888 (631) 673-1888
• Catch 24 ($)
  

  4.8 15 reviews
  Seafood, Seafood Markets

  237-07 Linden Blvd, Elmont, NY
  (516) 285-3700 (516) 285-3700
• Hook & Net ($$)
  

  4.4 10 reviews
  Seafood, Seafood Markets, Noodles

  414 1st St, Greenport, NY
  (631) 477-0055 (631) 477-0055
• Syosset Seafoods ($$)
  

  3.9 23 reviews
  Seafood, Seafood Markets

  293 Robbins Lane, Syosset, NY
  (516) 681-3474 (516) 681-3474
• Setauket Seafood ($$)
  

  4.8 17 reviews
  Seafood Markets

  230 Main St, East Setauket, NY
  (631) 751-2809 (631) 751-2809
• Tully's Fish Market & Snack Shack ($$)
  

  3.4 9 reviews
  Seafood, Seafood Markets

  78 Foster Ave, Hampton Bays, NY
  (631) 594-3968 (631) 594-3968
• Captain Ben's Fish Market ($$)
  

  4.0 22 reviews
  Seafood Markets

  319 Woodcleft Ave, Freeport, NY
  (516) 378-6575 (516) 378-6575
• Pine Aire Fish and Restaurant ($$)
  

  4.0 15 reviews
  Seafood, Seafood Markets

  140 Pine Aire Dr, Bay Shore, NY
  (631) 231-4467 (631) 231-4467
• Tristate Seafood ($$)
  

  4.9 12 reviews
  Seafood, Seafood Markets

  1288 Broadhollow Rd, Farmingdale, NY
  (631) 390-8627 (631) 390-8627
• Island Fish ($$)
  

  4.8 13 reviews
  Seafood, Seafood Markets

  Hook Creek Blvd And Sunrise Hwy, Valley Stream, NY
  (631) 698-7700 (631) 698-7700
• Shelter Island Seafood ($)
  

  4.8 23 reviews
  Seafood, Seafood Markets

  87 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 765-8181 (631) 765-8181
• Haskell's Seafood Market and Cafe ($$)
  

  4.7 10 reviews
  Cafe, Seafood Markets

  77A Main St, Westhampton Beach, NY
  (631) 288-7287 (631) 288-7287
• Mill Road Seafood ($$)
  

  4.3 24 reviews
  Seafood, Seafood Markets

  214 Mill Rd, Westhampton Beach, NY
  (631) 288-8184 (631) 288-8184
• I love steak NY ($)
  

  4.8 5 reviews
  Seafood Markets, Meat Shops

  168 Quality Plz, Hicksville, NY
  (855) 997-8325 (855) 997-8325
• Peterson's Seafood Market ($$)
  

  5.0 9 reviews
  Seafood Markets

  12 South Etna Ave, Montauk, NY
  (631) 668-5957 (631) 668-5957
• Gra-Bar Fish ($$)
  

  4.3 10 reviews
  Seafood Markets

  100 Court St, Copaigue, NY
  (516) 876-0441 (516) 876-0441
• Fishers Island Oyster Farm ($)
  

  4.7 9 reviews
  Seafood Markets

  4318 Oriental Ave, Fishers Island, NY
  (631) 788-7899 (631) 788-7899
• Blue Water Fish ($)
  

  4.8 8 reviews
  Seafood Markets, Seafood, Fish & Chips

  2 Sound Rd, Wading River, NY
  (631) 886-2715 (631) 886-2715
• J&M Seafood ($$)
  

  5.0 6 reviews
  Seafood Markets, Seafood

  248b Larkfield Rd, East Northport, NY
  (631) 306-4222 (631) 306-4222
• Pescaderia El Puerto ($$$)
  

  4.7 11 reviews
  Seafood, Seafood Markets

  212A Depot Rd, Huntington Station, NY
  (631) 425-4862 (631) 425-4862
• Gold Coast Lobster ($$)
  

  4.7 9 reviews
  Seafood Markets

  40 New York Ave, Huntington, NY
  (631) 424-8164 (631) 424-8164
• Mattituck Shellfish ($)
  

  4.4 9 reviews
  Seafood Markets

  468 Montauk Hwy, East Quogue, NY
  (631) 653-5040 (631) 653-5040
• Iavarone Bros ($)
  

  5.0 1 review
  Deli, Seafood Markets

  140 7th St, Garden City, NY
  (516) 266-8800 (516) 266-8800
• Levittown Fish Lobster City ($$)
  

  4.2 12 reviews
  Seafood, Seafood Markets

  140 Gardiners Ave, Levittown, NY
  (516) 731-3517 (516) 731-3517
• Fort Hill Seafood ($$)
  

  3.6 23 reviews
  Seafood, Seafood Markets

  113 E Main St, Huntington, NY
  (631) 427-2444 (631) 427-2444
• Wild Fork ($)
  

  4.0 2 reviews
  Seafood Markets, Meat Shops

  409 S Oyster Bay Rd, Plainview, NY
  (833) 300-9453 (833) 300-9453
• Deans Seafood ($$$)
  

  4.0 15 reviews
  Seafood, Seafood Markets

  19 Degnon Blvd, Bay Shore, NY
  (631) 969-0587 (631) 969-0587
• Hewlett Fish Market ($$)
  

  4.1 38 reviews
  Seafood, Seafood Markets, Catering

  1332 Broadway, Hewlett, NY
  (516) 374-2401 (516) 374-2401
• The Fish Place ($)
  

  4.3 12 reviews
  Seafood Markets

  1500 Sunrise Hwy, Copiague, NY
  (631) 842-0257 (631) 842-0257
• Justin's Chop Shop ($)
  

  3.0 1 review
  Seafood Markets, Meat Shops

  187 Montauk Hwy, Moriches, NY
  (631) 878-4555 (631) 878-4555
• Albertson Seafood Market ($)
  

  3.9 9 reviews
  Seafood Markets

  1032 Willis Ave, Albertson, NY
  (516) 218-3498 (516) 218-3498
• First Light Fisheries ($)
  

  4.7 11 reviews
  Seafood Markets, Seasonal

  395 Montauk Hwy, Wainscott, NY
  (631) 887-9458 (631) 887-9458
• Sweet Pea Kitchen ($$) - Closed
  

  4.3 3 reviews
  Sandwiches, Subs, Seafood Markets

  3370 Hillside Ave, New Hyde Park, NY
  (516) 742-6916 (516) 742-6916